@creayt said in Is sharing a single network connection between two servers dumb?:
@dashrender said in Is sharing a single network connection between two servers dumb?:
This isn't a NIC teaming situation.
The OP has one internet connection that needs to be split over two servers.
Normally one would install a switch and then run a cable from each server to the switch, and the switch to the internet... BUT - in this case, the OP doesn't have an open power socket for the switch (it would cost them more money) so they are looking for a way to do ICS (Internet connection sharing) from one server to the other.
This really seems like a bad idea. I'm guessing this means no Out of Band connections for the servers, and only a single connection for both servers. So if the first server dies, the second one becomes useless.
Really seems like a time to re-evaluate the priorities here - why are you in a DC if you can't afford these other seemingly needed things.
Thanks for the response! If the first server died, the datacenter team would pull the cable from the dead server and immediately plug it into the 2nd server, so there'd be a small window of downtime, but it'd theoretically take over all duties immediately. Agree it's a bad idea, but this is all for a hobby project where some downtime is acceptable and I'm trying to really be a cheap muhfuh 🙂
Not sure that would work. It would depend on how it's set up.