XenServer: Backup & Replication
-
@BRRABill Yes.
-
@DustinB3403 What actions have you taken with regards to logs been written to USB?
-
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@DustinB3403 What actions have you taken with regards to logs been written to USB?
That is still up in the air, I've been working to get a good, searchable solution in place and haven't been able to complete anything. Up until now logging has gone directly to the USB without issue.
-
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@DustinB3403 What actions have you taken with regards to logs been written to USB?
I've got two servers at two different sites. One is an R510 running XS6.5, been in place for ~2.5 years. No problems with the usb so far. The other site is an R900, been in place for ~ 4 years now. Has only just recently been upgraded to XenServer 7.0 from ProxMox. ProxMox isn't something I'd really recommend, and is even harder on usb drives than XenServer is. Switched to a new usb drive for the XenServer install, so it's only been 2 weeks it's run on that so far. Didn't have any issues with the usb drives.
-
Is cost the main reason for using USB vs a small capacity 2.5" HDD or even a 64 or 80GB SSD? (not sure sizes this small even exist anymore)
-
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
Is cost the main reason for using USB vs a small capacity 2.5" HDD or even a 64 or 80GB SSD? (not sure sizes this small even exist anymore)
Mostly so the hypervisor doesn't take up valuable drive slots. With the size even SSD is hitting today, that's quickly becoming less of a concern. My R900 with only 5 available drive bays makes me cry a little that it has so few slots. Couldn't argue with the price on it at the time.
-
@travisdh1 Since the current suggestion from folks like @scottalanmiller is to have (and use) a single large array (RAID 5 or 10) for XS o/s & VM storage, why would slot population be a concern?
-
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@travisdh1 Since the current suggestion from folks like @scottalanmiller is to have (and use) a single large array (RAID 5 or 10) for XS o/s & VM storage, why would slot population be a concern?
Five SSD bays is still pretty small. Even with 1TB drives, that's only 4TB usable. Often a limitation.
-
@scottalanmiller If one used your method of one large array, what is the advantage of using a 64GB USB stick? Just seems like your adding more complication?
-
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@scottalanmiller If one used your method of one large array, what is the advantage of using a 64GB USB stick? Just seems like your adding more complication?
It's to prevent updates (or something similar) from destroying your XS installation.
It's also a best practice to separate VDI/VM storage from the XS boot files.
-
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@scottalanmiller If one used your method of one large array, what is the advantage of using a 64GB USB stick? Just seems like your adding more complication?
Rapid restore, ability to image, ability to flip back and forth between versions.... and some platforms like ESXi can't do the single array without the USB/SD approach.
-
@DustinB3403 said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@DustinB3403 What actions have you taken with regards to logs been written to USB?
That is still up in the air, I've been working to get a good, searchable solution in place and haven't been able to complete anything. Up until now logging has gone directly to the USB without issue.
@BRRABill @DustinB3403 What do both of you plan to do regarding "logging + USB"?
-
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@scottalanmiller If one used your method of one large array, what is the advantage of using a 64GB USB stick? Just seems like your adding more complication?
Rapid restore, ability to image, ability to flip back and forth between versions.... and some platforms like ESXi can't do the single array without the USB/SD approach.
@scottalanmiller What do you prefer: one large array-[XS o/s + VMs] or USB (aka small SSD or HDD)-[XS o/s] + large array-[VMs] ??
-
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@scottalanmiller If one used your method of one large array, what is the advantage of using a 64GB USB stick? Just seems like your adding more complication?
Rapid restore, ability to image, ability to flip back and forth between versions.... and some platforms like ESXi can't do the single array without the USB/SD approach.
@scottalanmiller What do you prefer: one large array-[XS o/s + VMs] or USB (aka small SSD or HDD)-[XS o/s] + large array-[VMs] ??
When feasible, SD card for hypervisor and RAID array for VMs is ideal. But SD installation causes a lot of headaches for people that either have hardware that doesn't support it easily and/or aren't comfortable with getting logging pointed somewhere other than the SD card. You have to adjust the write behaviour manually or it will not likely be properly reliable. In which case, install to the main array becomes the better approach.
-
@scottalanmiller Thank for clearing that up.
Why can't we get a simple & concise guide to external logging?
-
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@scottalanmiller Thank for clearing that up.
Why can't we get a simple & concise guide to external logging?
Because XS isn't up and running in the NTG lab yet and no one else is actively working on it to completion.
-
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@scottalanmiller Thank for clearing that up.
Why can't we get a simple & concise guide to external logging?
Because XS isn't up and running in the NTG lab yet and no one else is actively working on it to completion.
Well, I am.
But can I borrow your brain for the next few days, haha.
-
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@DustinB3403 said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@DustinB3403 What actions have you taken with regards to logs been written to USB?
That is still up in the air, I've been working to get a good, searchable solution in place and haven't been able to complete anything. Up until now logging has gone directly to the USB without issue.
@BRRABill @DustinB3403 What do both of you plan to do regarding "logging + USB"?
Still working on it.
My goal is to get it to boot off USB, log externally, and write nothing to the USB.
-
@BRRABill said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@scottalanmiller Thank for clearing that up.
Why can't we get a simple & concise guide to external logging?
Because XS isn't up and running in the NTG lab yet and no one else is actively working on it to completion.
Well, I am.
But can I borrow your brain for the next few days, haha.
Go for it. First thing we need to do is test those new files.
-
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@BRRABill said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@FATeknollogee said in XenServer: Backup & Replication:
@scottalanmiller Thank for clearing that up.
Why can't we get a simple & concise guide to external logging?
Because XS isn't up and running in the NTG lab yet and no one else is actively working on it to completion.
Well, I am.
But can I borrow your brain for the next few days, haha.
Go for it. First thing we need to do is test those new files.
OK, when I get in today, I'll look at the logging mechanisms, and post to the other thread I have going.
