Millennial generation
-
I agree with @art_of_shred, just because we have these things - internet, cell phones, gaming consoles, doesn't make them a necessity. And if you have modern versions of these things you definitely aren't poor (and if you think you are, well in reality you are just a poor planner/budgeter, because clearly you can't afford those things, and your taking money away from something you need - a residence, clothing, food - to get them)
-
I see the same mentality being applied here as I do to health care - it exists so I deserve to have it.
Young people don't deserve internet, cell phones, etc, just like they don't deserve health care.
Do you find yourself missing out, maybe, I'll even go so far as to say, probably, but again, is that society's responsibility to ensure you have those things? I personally don't think so.
-
Young people don't deserve health care? What?
Also, how do you get a job if you don't have a phone? It's not even easy to get a job without access to the internet these days.
-
@Carnival-Boy said:
Young people don't deserve health care? What?
And that sums up so much of what is wrong in the United States.
My wife truly does not understand why I am working towards living in Japan.
-
@Dashrender said:
I see the same mentality being applied here as I do to health care - it exists so I deserve to have it.
Young people don't deserve internet, cell phones, etc, just like they don't deserve health care.
Do you find yourself missing out, maybe, I'll even go so far as to say, probably, but again, is that society's responsibility to ensure you have those things? I personally don't think so.
I understand what you mean and also agree. It's not that anyone "doesn't deserve" health care. The problem is the entitlement mentality where everyone believes that anything that is deemed good to have is their "right" to have free access to. And maybe everyone has forgotten, but land lines still exist, and they are, AFAIK, much cheaper than cell phones. Having a cell phone is not a right or a necessity. Food, clothes, shelter; that's the list of REAL necessities. And what's wrong with America is all the people who want to rob from the "haves" to give to the "have nots" because they "deserve" everything I have, but shouldn't need to work to get them, since I have done the work and earned enough to have them. They should just have everything handed to them, because somehow that's "fair". Oh, and I do not have health care. It's too stinking expensive and does basically nothing for me. But I get fined for not having it. I can go to a doctor every month (I don't) and pay the fines and still be thousands of dollars ahead of where I would be if I had health insurance and never even used it. What a joke.
-
@art_of_shred said:
And maybe everyone has forgotten, but land lines still exist, and they are, AFAIK, much cheaper than cell phones.
Lol. Wishful thinking. I dropped a landline and got a prepaid cellphone, because it was cheaper many years ago when I was in college. Landline go up to around $60/month. I'm still using prepaid service, and that was the first time I had a cell phone, you know when I paid for it. The first time I had Internet at home was in 2009/2010.
We actually grew up in a small appartment (that wasn't suppose to be an apartment) over a building company. We had no TV, not cable, no internet. We often eat had to eat a single meal a day, a mom my was working hard but, didn't make much. Especially to support two kids on her own as my dad had died from a heart attack so there was only one income. The teachers at school would always try to get us on welfare because things would be easier for us. Yet, my mom never did. She didn't think it was some else responsibility to pay for your way. You deal with the cards you've been dealt and figure out a way to make it work.
-
@art_of_shred said:
It's not that anyone "doesn't deserve" health care.
Oh but it is. You don't deserve a cell phone, you don't deserve a car, you don't even deserve a house or apt, or hell clothing or food. You definitely don't deserve health care.
All of these things come at a cost, you should should have to pony up for them, including health care. Now, that said, there has always been since the beginning the desire of some to help those less fortunate than themselves. These charities are what should be helping those who can't help themselves, not the government stealing our money to give to the have nots.
When those in power realized they could capitalize they power to even greater power by stealing from the rich to give to the poor, they have enabled all of these government programs to do just that.
I don't have any numbers, but I've read in the past that as our taxes lower, people in general are more philanthropic, and they will give to the charities, and those charities can help the less fortunate. This situation is superior to our current one because the charities themselves want to see people get back on their feet, there is no power in them keeping people dependent upon them. Unlike the government, where now that people get money from the government, the people will continue to vote people into power that continue to give them their free money.
-
@thecreativeone91 said:
Landline go up to around $60/month.
Landlines are $60/month where you are? damn!
They are $22 after taxes here before you add on the crap services they want you to have.
-
@Dashrender said:
@thecreativeone91 said:
Landline go up to around $60/month.
Landlines are $60/month where you are? damn!
They are $22 after taxes here before you add on the crap services they want you to have.
Well Verizon is expensive here, I guess they have to find a way to make money, because there don't offer DSL here, or TV/FiOS. There's one and only product called "Freedom Essentials" that you can get which is basic phone.
-
@thecreativeone91 said:
@Dashrender said:
@thecreativeone91 said:
Landline go up to around $60/month.
Landlines are $60/month where you are? damn!
They are $22 after taxes here before you add on the crap services they want you to have.
Well Verizon is expensive here, I guess they have to find a way to make money, because there don't offer DSL here, or TV/FiOS. There's one and only product called "Freedom Essentials" that you can get which is basic phone.
Do I recall correctly that you live in the sticks?
If that's right, yeah, then cellular is definitely the way to go.
-
@Dashrender said:
I don't have any numbers, but I've read in the past that as our taxes lower, people in general are more philanthropic, and they will give to the charities, and those charities can help the less fortunate. This situation is superior to our current one because the charities themselves want to see people get back on their feet, there is no power in them keeping people dependent upon them. Unlike the government, where now that people get money from the government, the people will continue to vote people into power that continue to give them their free money.
I don't agree there. Non-profits are just like governments - they make their money based on the needs of the dependents and the people who work there are people trying to accumulate power and money in both cases. Non-profits are not free of those motivations. They are just as corrupt as governments or worse, since they lack even the mandate and the oversight of the governed.
-
If the government doesn't do what it should for the people, people rebel, vote in another government, complain, etc. If a non-profit is corrupt, who finds out? Generally no one.
And even if money is not what is in play, talk to people dealing with NGOs in the third world, prostitutes follow the NGOs around like lost puppies because NGO workers so often trade goods for sex "off the record." The UN just investigated some of its own units and found that the sex trade was rampant and caused by the NGO / UN workers. Governments do this too, as do for profits, but not at the same rate. And a for profit employee stealing from the company to give gifts to a prostitute is easier to catch than an NGO worker withholding food or medical supplies until they get sex. One shows a gap in the records, one does not.
-
@Dashrender said:
@art_of_shred said:
It's not that anyone "doesn't deserve" health care.
Oh but it is. You don't deserve a cell phone, you don't deserve a car, you don't even deserve a house or apt, or hell clothing or food. You definitely don't deserve health care.
All of these things come at a cost, you should should have to pony up for them, including health care. Now, that said, there has always been since the beginning the desire of some to help those less fortunate than themselves. These charities are what should be helping those who can't help themselves, not the government stealing our money to give to the have nots.
When those in power realized they could capitalize they power to even greater power by stealing from the rich to give to the poor, they have enabled all of these government programs to do just that.
I don't have any numbers, but I've read in the past that as our taxes lower, people in general are more philanthropic, and they will give to the charities, and those charities can help the less fortunate. This situation is superior to our current one because the charities themselves want to see people get back on their feet, there is no power in them keeping people dependent upon them. Unlike the government, where now that people get money from the government, the people will continue to vote people into power that continue to give them their free money.
Kinda like the signs at the park that say don't feed the wildlife...
-
@scottalanmiller - it sounds like you're saying there is no solution then, or do you have a thought toward one?
-
@Dashrender said:
@scottalanmiller - it sounds like you're saying there is no solution then, or do you have a thought toward one?
Stop giving money to NGOs!!!
-
@scottalanmiller said:
@Dashrender said:
@scottalanmiller - it sounds like you're saying there is no solution then, or do you have a thought toward one?
Stop giving money to NGOs!!!
LOL - but that doesn't help the poor, that only helps those being ripped off by the NGOs
-
@Dashrender said:
LOL - but that doesn't help the poor, that only helps those being ripped off by the NGOs
Not according to a lot of people, it actually does help the poor. A great book to read that deals with how the poor are kept poor by NGOs is "Dark Star Safari." It's a travelogue but by a guy who hangs out with prime ministers and worked for NGOs and observes NGOs being used to keep corrupt governments rich and the poor really poor.
In theory, even NGOs that try to go good, might be part of the problem, not the solution.
-
@Dashrender said:
When those in power realized they could capitalize they power to even greater power by stealing from the rich to give to the poor, they have enabled all of these government programs to do just that.
But, that's how they make sure they get voted into the office you give everything to people who don't have it. and now, they of course will support you, because if they don't they won't have anything.
Heck they are starting programs now to give cell phones & service, internet connections (20Meg min download speed connections is there goal) and a new laptop to anyone on welfare in VA. They say these items are a necessity to life now, and they shouldn't go without it just because they can't afford it.
-
@thecreativeone91 said:
@Dashrender said:
When those in power realized they could capitalize they power to even greater power by stealing from the rich to give to the poor, they have enabled all of these government programs to do just that.
But, that's how they make sure they get voted into the office you give everything to people who don't have it. and now, they of course will support you, because if they don't they won't have anything.
Heck they are starting programs now to give cell phones & service, internet connections (20Meg min download speed connections is there goal) and a new laptop to anyone on welfare in VA. They say these items are a necessity to life now, and they shouldn't go without it just because they can't afford it.
Thanks for making my point
-
@thecreativeone91 said:
But, that's how they make sure they get voted into the office you give everything to people who don't have it. and now, they of course will support you, because if they don't they won't have anything.
Democracy. Where the poor base is in power and the rich, smart or caring are the helpless minority.
