BRRABill's Field Report With XenServer

Danp

@Dashrender Here's a related XO issue on GH.

BRRABill

@Dashrender Here's a related XO issue on GH.

I'm not sure if that is my issue.

I wonder if you can migrate from one standalone XS to another standalone. I am checking with @scottalanmiller on that one and will report back.

Danp

@BRRABill said:

I wonder if you can migrate from one standalone XS to another standalone. I am checking with @scottalanmiller on that one and will report back.

I can answer that for you. Yes, you can migrate between hosts in separate pools (technically, a lone XS is in it's own pool).

Dashrender

@Danp said:

@Dashrender Here's a related XO issue on GH.

Oh my issue had nothing to do with XenMotion - I was simply building a new VM - there were (are) a ton of network options.

Time to learn what they all mean.

BRRABill

@Danp said:

I can answer that for you. Yes, you can migrate between hosts in separate pools (technically, a lone XS is in it's own pool).

But only if they share storage, correct?

scottalanmiller

@BRRABill said:

@Danp said:

I can answer that for you. Yes, you can migrate between hosts in separate pools (technically, a lone XS is in it's own pool).

But only if they share storage, correct?

If it is using Xen's migrate system, yes.

BRRABill

I exported my XO VM from my test server, and imported onto the production server.

Came right back up. Awesome.

DustinB3403

@BRRABill said:

I exported my XO VM from my test server, and imported onto the production server.

Came right back up. Awesome.

That is how it's supposed to work, all of the time.

Congratulations.

JaredBusch

@DustinB3403 said:

@BRRABill said:

I exported my XO VM from my test server, and imported onto the production server.

Came right back up. Awesome.

That is how it's supposed to work, all of the time.

Congratulations.

With any Hypervisor.

BRRABill

Yes, but things always seem to have a habit of ... not working properly.

Danp

@scottalanmiller said:

@BRRABill said:

But only if they share storage, correct?

If it is using Xen's migrate system, yes.

XO will migrate a VM between local storage on two XS.

olivier

Figure 1: me actually lurking in this thread

BRRABill

@olivier

So, what is the official answer from up there?

Can XO migrate a VM fro one standalone XS to another XS?
Can you migrate the VM that XO is running on? (That gave me a "no can do" error.)

BRRABill

The VM that I exported seems to have created a vApp.

What is that?

olivier

@BRRABill

Yup
Yup

But you need to define a default SR on any pool you got. Eg: xe pool-param-set uuid=<pool-uuid> default-SR=<sr-uuid> (with the SR UUID of the local storage if you don't have a shared storage).

You can also do it with XenCenter or XO (see https://xen-orchestra.com/blog/set-the-xenserver-default-sr/ )

A live migration won't interrupt the VM, so even with XO on it: doesn't matter.

BRRABill

@olivier said:

But you need to define a default SR on any pool you got. Eg: xe pool-param-set uuid=<pool-uuid> default-SR=<sr-uuid> (with the SR UUID of the local storage if you don't have a shared storage).

You can also do it with XenCenter or XO (see https://xen-orchestra.com/blog/set-the-xenserver-default-sr/ )

But to clarify ... you DON'T need a pool? or do you?

Danp

@BRRABill said:

But to clarify ... you DON'T need a pool? or do you?

@Danp said:

I can answer that for you. Yes, you can migrate between hosts in separate pools (technically, a lone XS is in it's own pool).

olivier

Yes, as @Danp said, there is always a pool: a "single" host is by default in a pool with no name label.

XenCenter choose to hide this, not us.

BRRABill

@Danp @olivier

Thanks @Danp ... I think the thing that was throwing us here (who thought it was not possible outside a pool) was that a standalone is actually a pool

BRRABill

Converted my first physical server to a production XS this morning.

So far, so good.