New WiFi router recommendation
-
I currently have a linksys E2500 which I got many years ago,and is having several issues now. Planning to replace that and like to get some recommendation.
The first place I usually check is the wirecutter site and found Netgear R7000P as their top choice.
https://thewirecutter.com/reviews/best-wi-fi-router/Checked the device and looks bulky, doesnt seem to fit in the place where I have my current device. Next choices are synology which seems to be expensive and then TP Link, which is not my favorite.
My home devices includes; 2 smart tv (both on ethernet), and few computers, phones etc.
-
Do you want to stay with consumer stuff? I'm not sure how the Ubitquiti availability looks like in your part of the world, but that's always where I start.
-
Top recommendation is not to get a wifi router.
-
I've been looking into some of the mesh equipment for my neighbor. Narrowed it down to eero, amplifi, and Google.
-
@ambarishrh said in New WiFi router recommendation:
The first place I usually check is the wirecutter site and found Netgear R7000P as their top choice.
https://thewirecutter.com/reviews/best-wi-fi-router/
favorite.The problem here is that the best wifi router is still a wifi router. You've ruled out all truly good stuff by using only a consumer class category.
-
I'm sure I'll get railed for this but I really like the Linksys Velop setup I have. 2500 sq ft home and only need two to completely cover the whole place and I can sit out on the deck and "work" if I need to. The girls can be on their phones/tablets as well with no issues.
-
@scottalanmiller said in New WiFi router recommendation:
Top recommendation is not to get a wifi router.
What options should I be looking for?
-
@ambarishrh said in New WiFi router recommendation:
@scottalanmiller said in New WiFi router recommendation:
Top recommendation is not to get a wifi router.
What options should I be looking for?
I can only assume he means you should have a separate router and a AP.
Modem - Router - AP
-
@travisdh1 said in New WiFi router recommendation:
Do you want to stay with consumer stuff? I'm not sure how the Ubitquiti availability looks like in your part of the world, but that's always where I start.
I can see that there are resellers and distributors for Ubiquiti
Could this be a good choice for home? https://store.amplifi.com/products/amplifi-mesh-router
Local online store price is around AED 989.00 and is roughly $269.25
-
@ambarishrh said in New WiFi router recommendation:
@travisdh1 said in New WiFi router recommendation:
Do you want to stay with consumer stuff? I'm not sure how the Ubitquiti availability looks like in your part of the world, but that's always where I start.
I can see that there are resellers and distributors for Ubiquiti
Could this be a good choice for home? https://store.amplifi.com/products/amplifi-mesh-router
Local online store price is around AED 989.00 and is roughly $269.25
Why go to the lower quality, higher price consumer stuff instead of sticking to the cheaper, enterprise class stuff?
-
@ambarishrh said in New WiFi router recommendation:
@scottalanmiller said in New WiFi router recommendation:
Top recommendation is not to get a wifi router.
What options should I be looking for?
The normal... putting wifi into a router isn't a good way to go. Wifi and routing functions should be separate. You'd never mix them in a business, why not apply the same logic at home?
-
@scottalanmiller said in New WiFi router recommendation:
@ambarishrh said in New WiFi router recommendation:
@scottalanmiller said in New WiFi router recommendation:
Top recommendation is not to get a wifi router.
What options should I be looking for?
The normal... putting wifi into a router isn't a good way to go. Wifi and routing functions should be separate. You'd never mix them in a business, why not apply the same logic at home?
What would be your suggestions?
-
@ambarishrh said in New WiFi router recommendation:
@scottalanmiller said in New WiFi router recommendation:
@ambarishrh said in New WiFi router recommendation:
@scottalanmiller said in New WiFi router recommendation:
Top recommendation is not to get a wifi router.
What options should I be looking for?
The normal... putting wifi into a router isn't a good way to go. Wifi and routing functions should be separate. You'd never mix them in a business, why not apply the same logic at home?
What would be your suggestions?
Start by looking at something like the Ubiquiti ERX and an appropriate UBNT AP unit for your needs. There are about two to three of each router and AP that might be appropriate for home.
But having them separate you aren't forced to colocate two things that should rarely even be close to each other, and it lets you customize your purchase for your needs, and gives you flexibility on replacements and upgrades. Plus you tend to get far better quality for both.
-
I am leaning towards getting the https://store.amplifi.com/products/amplifi-mesh-router and later on get the https://store.amplifi.com/products/amplifi-hd-meshpoint if there are range issues. I don't think that would be a problem, my apartment is a small 1 bedroom around 1200 Sft area. I like the simplicity of the setup (from all the reviews from youtube) and liked the idea of having the option of using https://store.amplifi.com/products/amplifi-teleport
I hope I could just start with the mesh router and later on add the other two without any additional dependencies.
-
@scottalanmiller said in New WiFi router recommendation:
Ubiquiti ERX
I am currently looking at the ERX and AP as well, just so much of products on their page, trying to find what suits my need!
-
@ambarishrh said in New WiFi router recommendation:
@scottalanmiller said in New WiFi router recommendation:
Ubiquiti ERX
I am currently looking at the ERX and AP as well, just so much of products on their page, trying to find what suits my need!
Well, only one ERX. So that part is easy.
APs, you don't need high power or long range, so it's basically the cheapest model is the best. Even the cheapest Ubiquiti is SO much better than any wifi router wifi.
-
@ambarishrh said in New WiFi router recommendation:
I am leaning towards getting the https://store.amplifi.com/products/amplifi-mesh-router and later on get the https://store.amplifi.com/products/amplifi-hd-meshpoint if there are range issues. I don't think that would be a problem, my apartment is a small 1 bedroom around 1200 Sft area. I like the simplicity of the setup (from all the reviews from youtube) and liked the idea of having the option of using https://store.amplifi.com/products/amplifi-teleport
I hope I could just start with the mesh router and later on add the other two without any additional dependencies.
Single Ubiquiti AP should cover more like 400m / 4,000 sq ft.
-
You mean the mesh router would be sufficient? or still suggesting the router+AP combo?
I couldn't find the ERX & AP on the local online store, but the Amplifi mesh router is available. There are some distributors and resellers number in the region where I can check
Haven't heard anyone discussing about the Amplify Mesh. No one used this yet?
-
@ambarishrh I know one person that uses the Amplifi that why I considered it but I am going to switch to an Edgerouter 6P and AP combo.
-
I also use the AMPLIFI at one location and it works really well for a Wi-Fi router. If you’re not wanting anything except to serve basic Wi-Fi, it’s a good choice.
I want and need more than just that at home so I go with the separate router and access point. But those are more to manage by comparison.
