Server refresh - when should I?
-
Upgrading the RAM and the drives is probably 60-70% of the cost of a complete server replacement. The last purchase I made, the server and second power supply was under $3K compared to the nearly $4k for RAM and disk.
Consolidation will probably bring lower power bills, require less cooling (i.e. lower power bills) and fewer parts to maintain. In your situation I'd never personally want to go to less than two hosts.
Considering the advances in compute power, a single host can probably handle your entire environment right now.
-
@Dashrender said:
Upgrading the RAM and the drives is probably 60-70% of the cost of a complete server replacement. The last purchase I made, the server and second power supply was under $3K compared to the nearly $4k for RAM and disk.
I'll need to do some sums. But given that we can capitalise a new server over 5 years, but couldn't capitalise new RAM and disks for the old server, a new server may make the most sense financially.
-
There's plenty of things to factor in. How energy efficient are the new servers? If it's a healthy gap, you're losing money by keeping the old stuff running, and once you do the required math, you'll have a better idea on the lost cost savings by waiting. It might be a little, or it might be a lot, depending on the types of servers and configuration. Also, there's the consideration of density. A G8 has much more computing power than a G6, allowing it to hold a greater number of VMs. Theoretically, you could reduce the number of servers total, requiring less management overhead and operational cost.
Why are you still on ESXi 5.1? Your vSphere environment should be under maintenance. If your hosts are on the HCL for 5.5, go ahead and upgrade ESXi. If the hosts aren't on the HCL, it's a good sign that it's time to upgrade.
-
New servers typically make sense over upgrades. Upgrades have a huge price premium on parts, new servers have discounts.
New servers are smaller, faster, more reliable and more power efficient.
-
@alexntg said:
Why are you still on ESXi 5.1?
Because upgrading requires coming in on a Sunday and doing an upgrade that I'm not completely comfortable with. Basically, I don't like working Sundays and always put it off. It's not like I'd get paid or get time off in lieu, or if anyone I work with would even know I'd worked on Sunday.
TL;DR...I'm too lazy.
-
@scottalanmiller said:
New servers typically make sense over upgrades. Upgrades have a huge price premium on parts, new servers have discounts.
New servers are smaller, faster, more reliable and more power efficient.
Really, is there much of a difference between the 6th and 8th generation Proliants? They seem to have similar parts to me. I can see that moving to solid state drives will make a difference (but that's still very expensive), but otherwise?
-
@scottalanmiller said:
Five years is most definitely not too old for a server. In the enterprise space eight years is common and ten years isn't unheard of. At some point you pay too much in maintenance and that is really what makes the swing as long as everything else is still good.
I second his comment. Scott talked me into keeping our PowerEdge 2900 as a second virtual host and I am going to use it for development and application serving. We had some doubts about it not being up to the task but I turned on virtualization and it is working great. Though my RAID card says the battery needs replacement.
-
@Carnival-Boy said:
@scottalanmiller said:
New servers typically make sense over upgrades. Upgrades have a huge price premium on parts, new servers have discounts.
New servers are smaller, faster, more reliable and more power efficient.
Really, is there much of a difference between the 6th and 8th generation Proliants? They seem to have similar parts to me. I can see that moving to solid state drives will make a difference (but that's still very expensive), but otherwise?
There are improvements, yes. Cheaper, faster parts mostly. More cores at faster speeds for less money. And the ILO4 is sweet. It's not a huge leap. But old memory is super expensive.
-
Any issues migrating a VM from a G8 server to a G6 (and vice versa). I recall there can be issues when running different CPUs, although am I right in think that this only effects vMotion? We don't have vMotion, and so shut down the VMs and start them up on the new host.
-
@Carnival-Boy said:
Any issues migrating a VM from a G8 server to a G6 (and vice versa). I recall there can be issues when running different CPUs, although am I right in think that this only effects vMotion? We don't have vMotion, and so shut down the VMs and start them up on the new host.
If it's a cold move, you're fine. vMotion is where it gets tricky, and there's even ways around that.
-
@Carnival-Boy said:
Any issues migrating a VM from a G8 server to a G6 (and vice versa). I recall there can be issues when running different CPUs, although am I right in think that this only effects vMotion? We don't have vMotion, and so shut down the VMs and start them up on the new host.
As long as you are migrating cold you can move from an HP Intel box to a SuperMicro AMD box and it won't care. Only hot migrations are an issue.
