Xen Orchestra - Community Edition - Installing with Yarn

momurda

@danp I know how to check error logs. The point is the installer keeps on going after errors are encountered, then says everything is ok when it is done.
Like just now, "no package redis-server available" well that seems pretty important, why not err out there and tell me? Instead it goes through and says "Your xo is now ready, go to ip address and start using it"

bnrstnr

@momurda said in Xen Orchestra - Community Edition - Installing with Yarn:

3 separate versions of ubuntu and even different minor versions of them. 16, 17 and 18 over the last two years. Never works, theres alwasys some package not found, some configuration not supported, something that keeps it from working, yet the output still says it works.

I've deployed this at least a dozen times on all of these releases and I don't recall a time that it hasn't worked :man_shrugging:

It looks like a few of us are willing to help if you have the time to post your logs...

Danp

@momurda Understood. I'm sure the error checking could be improved. However, you haven't given any concrete examples to show where it is failing. If we can't duplicate the issue, then it is difficult for us to fix.

I've never seen the issue with redis-server. Can you provide a link to the ISO you are using to perform the OS install?

bnrstnr

Sanity check here, just installed on the regular 18.04 iso

Also, for shits and giggles, just did it on the mini.iso since I've never done it before. Selected "basic server" option with nothing but apt install openssh-server and ufw allow 80/tcp

@momurda Something funky is definitely going on. Any proxy or firewall stuff that could be blocking some of the packages? I seem to remember somebody having that problem in the past, too...

momurda

It is the 1804 server iso
The first step of the script fails and cant find redis-server, it then continues on through and installs everything else without a db.
0_1532984581348_bcab9e6c-28e0-4cbb-9a83-054bd2adca7b-image.png
https://mirror.pnl.gov/releases/bionic/ubuntu-18.04.1-live-server-amd64.iso

Danp

While the script should detect the error and abort, you can't hold it responsible for something on your end that is preventing the package from being found. This is what I get when I run the same command --

sudo apt search redis-server
Sorting... Done
Full Text Search... Done
golang-github-stvp-tempredis-dev/bionic,bionic 0.0~git20160122.0.83f7aae-1 all
  Go package to start and stop temporary redis-server processes

libtest-redisserver-perl/bionic,bionic 0.21-1 all
  redis-server runner for tests

python-hiredis/bionic 0.2.0-3 amd64
  redis protocol reader for Python 2.X using hiredis

python3-hiredis/bionic 0.2.0-3 amd64
  redis protocol reader for Python using hiredis

redis/bionic,bionic 5:4.0.9-1 all
  Persistent key-value database with network interface (metapackage)

redis-server/bionic,now 5:4.0.9-1 amd64 [installed]
  Persistent key-value database with network interface

Danp

@bnrstnr Did your install from the mini.iso work?

bnrstnr

@momurda said in Xen Orchestra - Community Edition - Installing with Yarn:

https://mirror.pnl.gov/releases/bionic/ubuntu-18.04.1-live-server-amd64.iso

For some reason most of the normal sources aren't available on the install from this iso.

running apt-cache policy gives me like 3 results, where the ISO I normally use, and even the mini.iso list like 15 sources

momurda

Its not something on my end.
The repo for redis-server isnt on the server iso repo.
It is on the regular ubuntu repo.

bnrstnr

@danp yes, the mini.iso worked

DustinB3403

@momurda said in Xen Orchestra - Community Edition - Installing with Yarn:

Its not something on my end.
The repo for redis-server isnt on the server iso repo.
It is on the regular ubuntu repo.

But that isn't something we should "fix", if you chose to use a repo that doesn't have the minimal requirements, you should install the requirements before installing this.

DustinB3403

I just had this conversation 2 maybe 3 weeks ago with a person who was complaining about the install failing because they chose an ISO that had cmdtest package, which breaks other dependencies.

If you're using a shitty iso, it's on you to fix the issues in that ISO, not on us to hope and pray we've caught and fixed every possible upstream issue.

DustinB3403

With that said, if you come and report the issue to us, we can try and assist you with the error you're encountering. But you can't expect us to account for things that we aren't specifically out looking for.

If redis-server isn't in your repos' add it, update and then try the install.

sudo add-apt-repository ppa:chris-lea/redis-server

sudo apt-get update

momurda

It is the official server iso from ubuntu. I also redownloaded this same iso from ubuntu.com and there is also no redis-server. Nowhere does your guide say to install prerequisites or add repositories to install. It says 'install ubuntu server and use this one line installer'. I did that and it fails 100% of the time. redis-server isnt on the ubuntu server iso repo by default.

black3dynamite

Use the alternate version
http://cdimage.ubuntu.com/releases/18.04/release/ubuntu-18.04.1-server-amd64.iso

Instead of the new default version
http://releases.ubuntu.com/18.04.1/ubuntu-18.04.1-live-server-amd64.iso

DustinB3403

@momurda said in Xen Orchestra - Community Edition - Installing with Yarn:

It is the official server iso from ubuntu. I also redownloaded this same iso from ubuntu.com and there is also no redis-server. Nowhere does your guide say to install prerequisites or add repositories to install. It says 'install ubuntu server and use this one line installer'. I did that and it fails 100% of the time. redis-server isnt on the ubuntu server iso repo by default.

But you've stated redis isn't included in the ISO you've used, normally you don't have to go and troubleshoot anything as the main Ubuntu and Debian distro's just work. (Debian does require some additional setup but that's adding sudo and curl).

Otherwise nothing is required. I'm testing with the ISO you've provided.

scottalanmiller

Even if not included, apt-get should go and find it.

momurda

Fixed by ditching ubuntu, my SOP today with ubuntu based installers and setups.
First try on debian, works with one warning about optional fsevents component.
This component only seems to be for osx so not sure why it is being triggered here during the install.

scottalanmiller

@momurda said in Xen Orchestra - Community Edition - Installing with Yarn:

Fixed by ditching ubuntu, my SOP today with ubuntu based installers and setups.
First try on debian, works with one warning about optional fsevents component.
This component only seems to be for osx so not sure why it is being triggered here during the install.

Very odd since most of the testing is Ubuntu.

bnrstnr

@momurda said in Xen Orchestra - Community Edition - Installing with Yarn:

First try on debian, works with one warning about optional fsevents component.

This happens with Ubuntu, too. Not sure what it's supposed to do, but none of the installs I've done ever have it.