XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions
-
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@Danp said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
So he only needs to license one of the servers even though there could be VMs running on both?
It's only during the automated migration that they can temporarily live on both, they are actively moving during the process. MS would never ping you for that. But if you want to be absolutely compliant, you offline them during the move, so they are never on more than one at a time.
No @scottalanmiller you cannot do this. He is building and running a Windows Server VM (based on his single DataCenter license) on two different physical servers. Each physical server will need a DataCenter license "assigned" to it for this to be legal.
The hypervisor of choice (XenServer in this case) has nothing to do with the equation.
-
@JaredBusch said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@Danp said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
So he only needs to license one of the servers even though there could be VMs running on both?
It's only during the automated migration that they can temporarily live on both, they are actively moving during the process. MS would never ping you for that. But if you want to be absolutely compliant, you offline them during the move, so they are never on more than one at a time.
No @scottalanmiller you cannot do this. He is building and running a Windows Server VM (based on his single DataCenter license) on two different physical servers. Each physical server will need a DataCenter license "assigned" to it for this to be legal.
The hypervisor of choice (XenServer in this case) has nothing to do with the equation.
That's what I said. It's not technically illegal during the migration if they are live, but MS would never ping you for it even though it isn't technically legal. So if you want to be totally technically legal, you have to power them down first, which I mentioned.
-
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@JaredBusch said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@Danp said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
So he only needs to license one of the servers even though there could be VMs running on both?
It's only during the automated migration that they can temporarily live on both, they are actively moving during the process. MS would never ping you for that. But if you want to be absolutely compliant, you offline them during the move, so they are never on more than one at a time.
No @scottalanmiller you cannot do this. He is building and running a Windows Server VM (based on his single DataCenter license) on two different physical servers. Each physical server will need a DataCenter license "assigned" to it for this to be legal.
The hypervisor of choice (XenServer in this case) has nothing to do with the equation.
That's what I said. It's not technically illegal during the migration if they are live, but MS would never ping you for it even though it isn't technically legal. So if you want to be totally technically legal, you have to power them down first, which I mentioned.
You are talking about migrating. I am talking about the fact that you have two different physical server with VMs running. No matter how temporary.
-
@JaredBusch said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@JaredBusch said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@Danp said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
So he only needs to license one of the servers even though there could be VMs running on both?
It's only during the automated migration that they can temporarily live on both, they are actively moving during the process. MS would never ping you for that. But if you want to be absolutely compliant, you offline them during the move, so they are never on more than one at a time.
No @scottalanmiller you cannot do this. He is building and running a Windows Server VM (based on his single DataCenter license) on two different physical servers. Each physical server will need a DataCenter license "assigned" to it for this to be legal.
The hypervisor of choice (XenServer in this case) has nothing to do with the equation.
That's what I said. It's not technically illegal during the migration if they are live, but MS would never ping you for it even though it isn't technically legal. So if you want to be totally technically legal, you have to power them down first, which I mentioned.
You are talking about migrating. I am talking about the fact that you have two different physical server with VMs running. No matter how temporary.
This is where Scott is agreeing with you, it's not strictly legal, but if they were audited in the middle of the migration, it's very unlikely MS would ding them for being on two pieces of hardware when it's clear the plan is to decom the old server.
Sure to be completely legal, they would have to shut down all VMs, migrate them, then start them all up on the new server, which is where you would be "assigning" the license at that time.
-
@Dashrender said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@JaredBusch said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@JaredBusch said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@Danp said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
So he only needs to license one of the servers even though there could be VMs running on both?
It's only during the automated migration that they can temporarily live on both, they are actively moving during the process. MS would never ping you for that. But if you want to be absolutely compliant, you offline them during the move, so they are never on more than one at a time.
No @scottalanmiller you cannot do this. He is building and running a Windows Server VM (based on his single DataCenter license) on two different physical servers. Each physical server will need a DataCenter license "assigned" to it for this to be legal.
The hypervisor of choice (XenServer in this case) has nothing to do with the equation.
That's what I said. It's not technically illegal during the migration if they are live, but MS would never ping you for it even though it isn't technically legal. So if you want to be totally technically legal, you have to power them down first, which I mentioned.
You are talking about migrating. I am talking about the fact that you have two different physical server with VMs running. No matter how temporary.
This is where Scott is agreeing with you, it's not strictly legal, but if they were audited in the middle of the migration, it's very unlikely MS would ding them for being on two pieces of hardware when it's clear the plan is to decom the old server.
Sure to be completely legal, they would have to shut down all VMs, migrate them, then start them all up on the new server, which is where you would be "assigning" the license at that time.
It is not a migration at all is my point. He is building them on a separate server for his own reasons.
-
@JaredBusch I may redo my post so I can provide additional detail to avoid the scrolling to get caught up.
My VMWare ESXi is live its 5.5. My XenServer is live its 7.0 But there are 0 of the machines from my VMWare coming over for longer term purposes. They are just windows 2008 servers and being decommissioned. I technically only have one server that I care about and thats my security system / access badge server but since my vendor finally (after a lonnnnnng call) gave me the software, I can install it , and install my backups to get my system going on my new hypervisor.
My new environment is going to be Windows 2012 R2 Data Center but push comes to shove I can buy an additional license because this existing server is basically End of Warranty. I'll keep adding parts as necessary but its there basically to be backup should I need one and also a test server. I plan on buying either a used server (thanks Slava) or getting a new server. I'm leaning toward used.
-
@JaredBusch said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@Dashrender said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@JaredBusch said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@JaredBusch said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
@Danp said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
So he only needs to license one of the servers even though there could be VMs running on both?
It's only during the automated migration that they can temporarily live on both, they are actively moving during the process. MS would never ping you for that. But if you want to be absolutely compliant, you offline them during the move, so they are never on more than one at a time.
No @scottalanmiller you cannot do this. He is building and running a Windows Server VM (based on his single DataCenter license) on two different physical servers. Each physical server will need a DataCenter license "assigned" to it for this to be legal.
The hypervisor of choice (XenServer in this case) has nothing to do with the equation.
That's what I said. It's not technically illegal during the migration if they are live, but MS would never ping you for it even though it isn't technically legal. So if you want to be totally technically legal, you have to power them down first, which I mentioned.
You are talking about migrating. I am talking about the fact that you have two different physical server with VMs running. No matter how temporary.
This is where Scott is agreeing with you, it's not strictly legal, but if they were audited in the middle of the migration, it's very unlikely MS would ding them for being on two pieces of hardware when it's clear the plan is to decom the old server.
Sure to be completely legal, they would have to shut down all VMs, migrate them, then start them all up on the new server, which is where you would be "assigning" the license at that time.
It is not a migration at all is my point. He is building them on a separate server for his own reasons.
OH! Not at all what I was responding to. The original title was "XS to XS Migration".... I thought that it was one XS machine to another, same pool (by matter of the recommended method) so all one cluster just re-balancing. Still not allowed, but even if an MS auditor was standing there I bet they'd look the other way and whistle while it rebalanced one time during the migration.
Built building separately like this, definitely not a migration in that sense. I see now.
-
@krisleslie said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
My new environment is going to be Windows 2012 R2 Data Center but push comes to shove I can buy an additional license because this existing server is basically End of Warranty. I'll keep adding parts as necessary but its there basically to be backup should I need one and also a test server. I plan on buying either a used server (thanks Slava) or getting a new server. I'm leaning toward used.
Tagging @slava for you
-
I mean I still would want to follow the 1 SMB Server principle, but I find it getting harder to do considering I need a video monitoring host
Last but not least, getting sorda into VDI but the baby stuff, using Windows Multipoint Server. -
@krisleslie said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
Last but not least, getting sorda into VDI but the baby stuff, using Windows Multipoint Server.
That's not VDI at all. That's just multiple monitors on a single OS. That's related to RDS without remote access. Not related to VDI.
-
@krisleslie said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
I mean I still would want to follow the 1 SMB Server principle, but I find it getting harder to do considering I need a video monitoring host
What does that host do?
-
@scottalanmiller said in XenServer Host to Host Migration Questions:
nciple, but I find it getting harder to do conside
Well since this will be my first venture into using a video server, not sure how much system to give something like that.
