Random Thread - Anything Goes
-
Image two kids in a car. Which one would you ticket? You can't ticket both.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@hobbit666 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
Had a random thought this morning while making a cuppa for the wife before I left for work......
I a world of "self drive" cars will we need a driver's license? What's to stop the kids jumping in and telling the car they want to go to the zoo
It's been an assumption that it will be the same as a taxi. No license needed for a taxi. As there is no driver, no drivers license.
Would that still apply if you are the owner of the car?
-
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@hobbit666 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
Had a random thought this morning while making a cuppa for the wife before I left for work......
I a world of "self drive" cars will we need a driver's license? What's to stop the kids jumping in and telling the car they want to go to the zoo
It's been an assumption that it will be the same as a taxi. No license needed for a taxi. As there is no driver, no drivers license.
Hm. I could see them eventually having to live up to a certain set of standards--a license of sorts
-
How I feel this week... only I haven't quit drinking coffee.
-
@wirestyle22 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@hobbit666 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
Had a random thought this morning while making a cuppa for the wife before I left for work......
I a world of "self drive" cars will we need a driver's license? What's to stop the kids jumping in and telling the car they want to go to the zoo
It's been an assumption that it will be the same as a taxi. No license needed for a taxi. As there is no driver, no drivers license.
Hm. I could see them eventually having to live up to a certain set of standards--a license of sorts
They already do.
-
@black3dynamite said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@hobbit666 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
Had a random thought this morning while making a cuppa for the wife before I left for work......
I a world of "self drive" cars will we need a driver's license? What's to stop the kids jumping in and telling the car they want to go to the zoo
It's been an assumption that it will be the same as a taxi. No license needed for a taxi. As there is no driver, no drivers license.
Would that still apply if you are the owner of the car?
Of course, you don't need a license to own a car now. Or to own a taxi. It's being the driver you need a license for. Always has been. A five year old with money can buy as many cars as he wants.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@wirestyle22 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@hobbit666 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
Had a random thought this morning while making a cuppa for the wife before I left for work......
I a world of "self drive" cars will we need a driver's license? What's to stop the kids jumping in and telling the car they want to go to the zoo
It's been an assumption that it will be the same as a taxi. No license needed for a taxi. As there is no driver, no drivers license.
Hm. I could see them eventually having to live up to a certain set of standards--a license of sorts
They already do.
Wouldn't you consider that to be a license? Isn't that the point of needing to get one? Other than revenue for the state
-
I think the core question here is, if a self driving car violates a human traffic law, who is in trouble? The car or the human/owner of the car? Ticket the car and you now have active Civil Asset Forfeiture. Ticket the human, but you can't because they did not actually cause the violation.
-
@wirestyle22 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@wirestyle22 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@hobbit666 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
Had a random thought this morning while making a cuppa for the wife before I left for work......
I a world of "self drive" cars will we need a driver's license? What's to stop the kids jumping in and telling the car they want to go to the zoo
It's been an assumption that it will be the same as a taxi. No license needed for a taxi. As there is no driver, no drivers license.
Hm. I could see them eventually having to live up to a certain set of standards--a license of sorts
They already do.
Wouldn't you consider that to be a license? Isn't that the point of needing to get one? Other than revenue for the state
But it is the car that has to be legal to be on the road, not the owner. There is no reason to be weird here. Licensing someone to OWN a car? How weird is that. Makes no sense and has no purpose. The owner can't influence how the car operates, what would the license be for and what purpose would it serve?
-
@nerdydad said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
I think the core question here is, if a self driving car violates a human traffic law, who is in trouble?
We already have laws that cover that. The driver. Who is the driver of a self driving car? Hint: not a person.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@nerdydad said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
I think the core question here is, if a self driving car violates a human traffic law, who is in trouble?
We already have laws that cover that. The driver. Who is the driver of a self driving car? Hint: not a person.
Exactly. What if the car had no occupants and was driving itself to its owner's location?
-
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@nerdydad said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
I think the core question here is, if a self driving car violates a human traffic law, who is in trouble?
We already have laws that cover that. The driver. Who is the driver of a self driving car? Hint: not a person.
If the car hits someone its forced to be a bit coin miner for x amount of time, revenue going to the state
-
@wirestyle22 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@wirestyle22 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@hobbit666 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
Had a random thought this morning while making a cuppa for the wife before I left for work......
I a world of "self drive" cars will we need a driver's license? What's to stop the kids jumping in and telling the car they want to go to the zoo
It's been an assumption that it will be the same as a taxi. No license needed for a taxi. As there is no driver, no drivers license.
Hm. I could see them eventually having to live up to a certain set of standards--a license of sorts
They already do.
Wouldn't you consider that to be a license? Isn't that the point of needing to get one? Other than revenue for the state
What?
You don't need a driver's license to get in a cab and have the cab take you places. Why would you need a license to ride in a self driving car?
As for revenue, you'll still need ID, so instead of getting a Driver's License and also using that as an ID, you just get an ID from the state.
-
@nerdydad said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
The car or the human/owner of the car?
You ticket the driver today, no reason to change the law. You don't ticket passengers for the driver's decision. Whether there is only one or ten passengers, don't matter, you don't ticket people who aren't driving.
-
@dashrender said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@wirestyle22 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@wirestyle22 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@hobbit666 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
Had a random thought this morning while making a cuppa for the wife before I left for work......
I a world of "self drive" cars will we need a driver's license? What's to stop the kids jumping in and telling the car they want to go to the zoo
It's been an assumption that it will be the same as a taxi. No license needed for a taxi. As there is no driver, no drivers license.
Hm. I could see them eventually having to live up to a certain set of standards--a license of sorts
They already do.
Wouldn't you consider that to be a license? Isn't that the point of needing to get one? Other than revenue for the state
What?
You don't need a driver's license to get in a cab and have the cab take you places. Why would you need a license to ride in a self driving car?
As for revenue, you'll still need ID, so instead of getting a Driver's License and also using that as an ID, you just get an ID from the state.
I don't mean the person, I mean the car
-
@nerdydad said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@nerdydad said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
I think the core question here is, if a self driving car violates a human traffic law, who is in trouble?
We already have laws that cover that. The driver. Who is the driver of a self driving car? Hint: not a person.
Exactly. What if the car had no occupants and was driving itself to its owner's location?
Right, great example. Empty cars doing deliveries will be insanely common. Or cars just moving themselves around, sometimes at the request of a city or police (parked cars needed to move for an emergency, for example.) Would you ticket the city or the police?
And loads of cars will be operated by companies. Likely nearly all of them, within not too long, and not owned by individuals. Who do you ticket when there is no human occupant, driver OR owner?
-
@wirestyle22 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@dashrender said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@wirestyle22 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@wirestyle22 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@hobbit666 said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
Had a random thought this morning while making a cuppa for the wife before I left for work......
I a world of "self drive" cars will we need a driver's license? What's to stop the kids jumping in and telling the car they want to go to the zoo
It's been an assumption that it will be the same as a taxi. No license needed for a taxi. As there is no driver, no drivers license.
Hm. I could see them eventually having to live up to a certain set of standards--a license of sorts
They already do.
Wouldn't you consider that to be a license? Isn't that the point of needing to get one? Other than revenue for the state
What?
You don't need a driver's license to get in a cab and have the cab take you places. Why would you need a license to ride in a self driving car?
As for revenue, you'll still need ID, so instead of getting a Driver's License and also using that as an ID, you just get an ID from the state.
I don't mean the person, I mean the car
You mean a license PLATE? Sure, the car will need an ID.
-
Here is the thing... all modern driving laws already totally cover self driving cars. The situation is already handled and handled well. There's no need or purpose for a change. The needs of driving remain the same. The only new laws needed are the ones that allow self driving cars onto the road, and those are for vendors not passengers. As people who buy or ride in cars, none of this changes for us in any way.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
@nerdydad said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
The car or the human/owner of the car?
You ticket the driver today, no reason to change the law. You don't ticket passengers for the driver's decision. Whether there is only one or ten passengers, don't matter, you don't ticket people who aren't driving.
That question was actually rhetorical as I was getting to my point. But the point is, how to traffic violations become rectified? Or are we going to need traffic laws anymore?
-
@scottalanmiller said in Random Thread - Anything Goes:
at the request of a city or police (parked cars needed to move for an emergency, for example.) Would you ticket the city or the
when there is no driver, the owner is the one to get the ticket, I would guess.
I do have a problem with this considering that the owner of the car, let's say it's Scott's car, is not the programmer of the system, nor can he mod it, so it seems kinda unjust to claim that Scott is to blame if the car is in an accident that is the car's fault.
