The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences
-
@travisdh1 said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
@dafyre said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
@scottalanmiller said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
@travisdh1 said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
@scottalanmiller said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
avoiding lightweight and low resource desktops no matter how cool they are
While I love my LXDE and XFCE, there are reasons I don't recommend them to most people.
Same here. Or Mate.
Just curious as to why not Mate?
I haven't used Mate myself, but I'd imagine it's along the lines of LXDE and XFCE. They're just very basic, most of your system management is still done via a terminal emulator. They're for those times when UNIX admins want a web browser.
Exactly. Its like a slightly more overhead version of those.
-
good list for comparison. Esp for Windows users moving over who are new. Those distros listed are the most complete package generally.
One thing to look at is blu ray playback. I know most people are using network storage options for viewing movies, but going to Redbox and getting a bluray is convenient for new releases.
I havent had much luck getting those to work in Linux. -
Why Fedora over Korora for a user desktop experience?
Korora with Cinnamon is a really nice experience.
-
@JaredBusch said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
Why Fedora over Korora for a user desktop experience?
I totally thought about that and here is my logic...
- Korora's focus is Cinnamon, that's covered by Mint (who makes Cinnamon.)
- Korora's Gnome 3 is heavily modified.
- Korora is not the "reference implementation" of Gnome 3
-
@scottalanmiller said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
@JaredBusch said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
Why Fedora over Korora for a user desktop experience?
I totally thought about that and here is my logic...
- Korora's focus is Cinnamon, that's covered by Mint (who makes Cinnamon.)
- Korora's Gnome 3 is heavily modified.
- Korora is not the "reference implementation" of Gnome 3
Works. Just wondering..
I don't like Mint because it seems to be a slow update cycle. Has that changed?
-
@JaredBusch said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
I don't like Mint because it seems to be a slow update cycle. Has that changed?
No, and I agree, that's a big reason why I don't prefer it, too. But I'm trying to not make it a showcase of "things Scott likes" but more a base survey of the Linux desktop ecosystems that makes for a solid launching pad into other things that people might want to explore.
I will of course mention Korora and Ubuntu, both super important, especially Ubuntu. And others, there are loads of experimental desktops that are interesting, but I can't show everything.
-
I've played with Solus and must say that it is very slick.
-
still young but this is the reference kde now.
-
@matteo-nunziati said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
still young but this is the reference kde now.
Not really. It's a secondary KDE bolt on to Ubuntu bypassing the mainline Kubuntu. openSuse remains the only major distro building with KDE in mind.
-
What about Antergos? Based on Arch Linux but user friendly.
-
@black3dynamite said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
What about Antergos? Based on Arch Linux but user friendly.
I've never seen it, looking now.
-
@black3dynamite said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
What about Antergos? Based on Arch Linux but user friendly.
@black3dynamite said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
What about Antergos? Based on Arch Linux but user friendly.
Looks like a neat idea, but does it provide something important that is missing from the others? It doesn't have a focused desktop experience, it's primarily focused on Cinnamon which is covered from Mint where Cinnamon is developed.
-
Seems to me Elementary OS is only one focused on one Desktop.
if Elementary OS comes preinstalled with gdebi and configured as the default package installer like Linux Mint that would help alot. -
@black3dynamite said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
Seems to me Elementary OS is only one focused on one Desktop.
Fedora, CentOS, openSuse, Ubuntu, Solus, Mint... they all focus on single desktops. They "offer" others, but they don't focus on them.
-
@scottalanmiller said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
@black3dynamite said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
Seems to me Elementary OS is only one focused on one Desktop.
Fedora, CentOS, openSuse, Ubuntu, Solus, Mint... they all focus on single desktops. They "offer" others, but they don't focus on them.
But how many end users will know that those desktops is the main focus? Ubuntu, Fedora, Solus, and Elementary OS makes it easier.
That was the annoying thing about my first linux experience years ago. Not knowing which desktop is the main focus. Believe it or not, when unity was first introduced that made it easier on me to know that it's the main focus.
-
@black3dynamite said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
But how many end users will know that those desktops is the main focus?
They don't really need to know.
-
@black3dynamite said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
That was the annoying thing about my first linux experience years ago. Not knowing which desktop is the main focus. Believe it or not, when unity was first introduced that made it easier on me to know that it's the main focus.
What made it clear that Unity was the main focus compared, for example, to KDE on openSuse which has been its focused for decades and they were very, very public about that long before Ubuntu even existed?
-
@scottalanmiller said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
@black3dynamite said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
That was the annoying thing about my first linux experience years ago. Not knowing which desktop is the main focus. Believe it or not, when unity was first introduced that made it easier on me to know that it's the main focus.
What made it clear that Unity was the main focus compared, for example, to KDE on openSuse which has been its focused for decades and they were very, very public about that long before Ubuntu even existed?
It's been awhile but I think it has something do with not liking KDE or comfortable with openSuse back then.
-
@scottalanmiller said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
@black3dynamite said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
But how many end users will know that those desktops is the main focus?
They don't really need to know.
That's true until the user's wise up and asked, why so many desktop choices from Linux Mint. Is one better than the other? Which one is supported more than other? That's why avoid bringing up Mint to some users because of those questions.
-
@black3dynamite said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
@scottalanmiller said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
@black3dynamite said in The Quintessential Linux Desktop Experiences:
But how many end users will know that those desktops is the main focus?
They don't really need to know.
That's true until the user's wise up and asked, why so many desktop choices from Linux Mint. Is one better than the other? Which one is supported more than other? That's why avoid bringing up Mint to some users because of those questions.
But that's the point.
