RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?
-
@scottalanmiller said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@jrc said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
Also, isn't RAIN basically an array of RAIDs ??
No, that would be Network RAID.
That how would you define RAIN? Wouldn't each node be a NAS of some sort, and more than likely that NAS would be configured with RAID, or am I missing something?
-
@jrc said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@scottalanmiller said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@jrc said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
Also, isn't RAIN basically an array of RAIDs ??
No, that would be Network RAID.
That how would you define RAIN? Wouldn't each node be a NAS of some sort, and more than likely that NAS would be configured with RAID, or am I missing something?
It depends. RAIN is a blanket term for a lot of things, unlike RAID which is quite specific. You could make a great argument that Network RAID is a member of the RAIN family.
But in general terms, if you use Network RAID (treating each node as a disk) it's not called RAIN.
RAIN is assumed to have nodal awareness. RAID treats all members as drives and can't tell what is a node, and what is a drive.
-
@scottalanmiller said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@jrc said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@scottalanmiller said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@jrc said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
Also, isn't RAIN basically an array of RAIDs ??
No, that would be Network RAID.
That how would you define RAIN? Wouldn't each node be a NAS of some sort, and more than likely that NAS would be configured with RAID, or am I missing something?
It depends. RAIN is a blanket term for a lot of things, unlike RAID which is quite specific. You could make a great argument that Network RAID is a member of the RAIN family.
But in general terms, if you use Network RAID (treating each node as a disk) it's not called RAIN.
RAIN is assumed to have nodal awareness. RAID treats all members as drives and can't tell what is a node, and what is a drive.
What type of system would be a good example of RAIN? Gluster? Ceph? or am I totally missing the boat?
-
@dafyre said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@scottalanmiller said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@jrc said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@scottalanmiller said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@jrc said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
Also, isn't RAIN basically an array of RAIDs ??
No, that would be Network RAID.
That how would you define RAIN? Wouldn't each node be a NAS of some sort, and more than likely that NAS would be configured with RAID, or am I missing something?
It depends. RAIN is a blanket term for a lot of things, unlike RAID which is quite specific. You could make a great argument that Network RAID is a member of the RAIN family.
But in general terms, if you use Network RAID (treating each node as a disk) it's not called RAIN.
RAIN is assumed to have nodal awareness. RAID treats all members as drives and can't tell what is a node, and what is a drive.
What type of system would be a good example of RAIN? Gluster? Ceph? or am I totally missing the boat?
Yes, Cluster, CEPH, SCRIBE, Exablox... all RAIN. Traditional RAIN by everyone's standards.
-
@scottalanmiller said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@dafyre said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@scottalanmiller said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@jrc said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@scottalanmiller said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@jrc said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
Also, isn't RAIN basically an array of RAIDs ??
No, that would be Network RAID.
That how would you define RAIN? Wouldn't each node be a NAS of some sort, and more than likely that NAS would be configured with RAID, or am I missing something?
It depends. RAIN is a blanket term for a lot of things, unlike RAID which is quite specific. You could make a great argument that Network RAID is a member of the RAIN family.
But in general terms, if you use Network RAID (treating each node as a disk) it's not called RAIN.
RAIN is assumed to have nodal awareness. RAID treats all members as drives and can't tell what is a node, and what is a drive.
What type of system would be a good example of RAIN? Gluster? Ceph? or am I totally missing the boat?
Yes, Cluster, CEPH, SCRIBE, Exablox... all RAIN. Traditional RAIN by everyone's standards.
I'm familiar with Gluster and Ceph. Exablox is not open source...
SCRIBE is done by @scale -- so it's not open source, right?
-
Well, I think you guys really RAIN'd on this guys parade. Good work.
-
@dafyre said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@scottalanmiller said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@dafyre said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@scottalanmiller said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@jrc said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@scottalanmiller said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@jrc said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
Also, isn't RAIN basically an array of RAIDs ??
No, that would be Network RAID.
That how would you define RAIN? Wouldn't each node be a NAS of some sort, and more than likely that NAS would be configured with RAID, or am I missing something?
It depends. RAIN is a blanket term for a lot of things, unlike RAID which is quite specific. You could make a great argument that Network RAID is a member of the RAIN family.
But in general terms, if you use Network RAID (treating each node as a disk) it's not called RAIN.
RAIN is assumed to have nodal awareness. RAID treats all members as drives and can't tell what is a node, and what is a drive.
What type of system would be a good example of RAIN? Gluster? Ceph? or am I totally missing the boat?
Yes, Cluster, CEPH, SCRIBE, Exablox... all RAIN. Traditional RAIN by everyone's standards.
I'm familiar with Gluster and Ceph. Exablox is not open source...
SCRIBE is done by @scale -- so it's not open source, right?
Correct, it is closed source.
-
@pchiodo said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
Well, I think you guys really RAIN'd on this guys parade. Good work.
You were hoping for a RAIDing party?
-
@scottalanmiller With this group? You're just spinning in place.
-
@pchiodo said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@scottalanmiller With this group? You're just spinning in place.
Oh... that's a good one.
-
@scottalanmiller said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
@pchiodo said in RAID - the king of the storage landscape or legacy?:
Well, I think you guys really RAIN'd on this guys parade. Good work.
You were hoping for a RAIDing party?
~Grabs Knife of Slicing. (Knife made from computer case, +2 bleeding damage)
~Grabs Winchester Shield (+1 defense, -255 data retention).
~Grabs Umbrella (+50 resistance to water, -50 resistance to lightning).
~Grabs Book of SPELLS. (Stupidly Powerful Extra Long Ludicrous Sayings, +25 Magic Damage)There, I'm ready.
