Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?
-
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
So wait, are slots 0 and 1 the 2.5" bays?
This R510 has 8x 3.5" drive bays. My SAS drives are 2.5" but I have the Dell caddie spacer things..
But you can't scrounge up eight drives, only six, that match?
I have a lot of low capacity drives (like 300GB drives) but it's a mix of 10k and 15k and then some are dead and some aren't.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
My thinking is that I'd like the OS partition to be fast as possible, because why not.
Couple terminology pieces...
Your HV is what runs the system, not the OS. Hyper-V is an HV, Windows is an OS. Your OSes are in your VMs and will go on the big RAID array. Your HV alone, which is tiny and has no performance needs, is what will go on the SSD array.
They are not partitions, they are arrays. Partitions are a completely different, but very specific, concept.
Sorry, when I say OS in this case, I mean Hyper-V. I'm installing the bare-metal Windows Hyper-V 2016 hypervisor.
Right, Hyper-V is not an OS. Avoid that term.
Also there is more confusion about the product. Let's break this down.
Hyper-V is the Type 1 hypervisor, that means it is always bare metal. Never use the term "bare metal" with Hyper-V, because that is implied. It's redundant, but implies that you are confused and think that there is another option.
I just wanted to make it clear that I wasn't talking about the Hyper-V role in Windows.
Right, but that doesn't imply that in any way. But calling your install Windows Hyper-V, instead of Hyper-V, implied that you were doing the role. Because the role is every bit as bare metal as the normal install, saying bare metal doesn't mean anything at all. But including the word Windows would mean a lot.
How is installing the Windows Hyper-V role on a Windows Server installation the same as installing the hypervisor? I thought that installing the role was worse than just installing the hypervisor since it's kinda sitting on top of the Windows Server OS and adds overhead or something.
-
Installing the role moves the previous bare metal installation to be above the hypervisor.
The windows server installation needs to be licensed and activated.
It binds the 2 VM's you can have to that hardware.
The part you are mixing up is that Installing the role on Windows (10 or Server 2016 or any Windows environment) is that it is taking that environment and transforming it into the Dom0.
The control domain.
So all of the limitations of that control domain are then brought into the hypervisor. Where as installing Hyper-V creates a completely free to use control domain at $0 cost to you, and without any of the restrictions from a Microsoft environment.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
Dell will often reject consumer drives. Or any non-Dell drives.
What? What do you mean reject them? They will complain, but the drives work just fine... At least everything I have tested.
-
@dustinb3403 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
Installing the role moves the previous bare metal installation to be above the hypervisor.
The windows server installation needs to be licensed and activated.
It binds the 2 VM's you can have to that hardware.
The part you are mixing up is that Installing the role on Windows (10 or Server 2016 or any Windows environment) is that it is taking that environment and transforming it into the Dom0.
The control domain.
So all of the limitations of that control domain are then brought into the hypervisor. Where as installing Hyper-V creates a completely free to use control domain at $0 cost to you, and without any of the restrictions from a Microsoft environment.
oh cool. I didn't know that.. I really need to do some learning..
-
@aaronstuder said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
Dell will often reject consumer drives. Or any non-Dell drives.
What? What do you mean reject them? They will complain, but the drives work just fine... At least everything I have tested.
Yeah I'm using a non-Dell SSD right now in this server and it's working fine.
-
Maybe I should see if I can install Hyper-V on an SD card.. I have an iDRAC with the card slot
-
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
Maybe I should see if I can install Hyper-V on an SD card.. I have an iDRAC with the card slot
No, don't do that. MS used to semi-support that long ago. Now they do not at all.
-
@aaronstuder said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
Dell will often reject consumer drives. Or any non-Dell drives.
What? What do you mean reject them? They will complain, but the drives work just fine... At least everything I have tested.
Depends on the drives and the controller. Often it won't work, sometimes it just partially works.
-
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
My thinking is that I'd like the OS partition to be fast as possible, because why not.
Couple terminology pieces...
Your HV is what runs the system, not the OS. Hyper-V is an HV, Windows is an OS. Your OSes are in your VMs and will go on the big RAID array. Your HV alone, which is tiny and has no performance needs, is what will go on the SSD array.
They are not partitions, they are arrays. Partitions are a completely different, but very specific, concept.
Sorry, when I say OS in this case, I mean Hyper-V. I'm installing the bare-metal Windows Hyper-V 2016 hypervisor.
Right, Hyper-V is not an OS. Avoid that term.
Also there is more confusion about the product. Let's break this down.
Hyper-V is the Type 1 hypervisor, that means it is always bare metal. Never use the term "bare metal" with Hyper-V, because that is implied. It's redundant, but implies that you are confused and think that there is another option.
I just wanted to make it clear that I wasn't talking about the Hyper-V role in Windows.
Right, but that doesn't imply that in any way. But calling your install Windows Hyper-V, instead of Hyper-V, implied that you were doing the role. Because the role is every bit as bare metal as the normal install, saying bare metal doesn't mean anything at all. But including the word Windows would mean a lot.
How is installing the Windows Hyper-V role on a Windows Server installation the same as installing the hypervisor? I thought that installing the role was worse than just installing the hypervisor since it's kinda sitting on top of the Windows Server OS and adds overhead or something.
It's worse, because of licensing binding, and because it installs Windows bloat on top of Hyper-V. But it doesn't alter Hyper-V itself in any way.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
Maybe I should see if I can install Hyper-V on an SD card.. I have an iDRAC with the card slot
No, don't do that. MS used to semi-support that long ago. Now they do not at all.
k then.. I guess I'll just leave the single SSD in and finish installing it to that. I started the install process to one Intel SSD then paused to come post my questions here.
-
@aaronstuder said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
Dell will often reject consumer drives. Or any non-Dell drives.
What? What do you mean reject them? They will complain, but the drives work just fine... At least everything I have tested.
Willard found out that some SSDs just don't work in Dell servers..
-
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
Maybe I should see if I can install Hyper-V on an SD card.. I have an iDRAC with the card slot
No, don't do that. MS used to semi-support that long ago. Now they do not at all.
k then.. I guess I'll just leave the single SSD in and finish installing it to that. I started the install process to one Intel SSD then paused to come post my questions here.
FYI, this is a complete waste of a SSD drive. More IOPs wasted on something that can't/won't use it.
Why are you setting up Hyper-V today when you don't have drives to store the VM's on? Why not wait until you buy those 6+ large HDDs and make a OBR10 and install Hyper-V on there.
It doesn't need to be 8 drives, 6 is fine if that gives you the storage you need. Hyper-V install itself is pretty small, I'm guessing 20 GB or less.
-
@dashrender said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
Maybe I should see if I can install Hyper-V on an SD card.. I have an iDRAC with the card slot
No, don't do that. MS used to semi-support that long ago. Now they do not at all.
k then.. I guess I'll just leave the single SSD in and finish installing it to that. I started the install process to one Intel SSD then paused to come post my questions here.
FYI, this is a complete waste of a SSD drive. More IOPs wasted on something that can't/won't use it.
Why are you setting up Hyper-V today when you don't have drives to store the VM's on? Why not wait until you buy those 6+ large HDDs and make a OBR10 and install Hyper-V on there.
It doesn't need to be 8 drives, 6 is fine if that gives you the storage you need. Hyper-V install itself is pretty small, I'm guessing 20 GB or less.
Hmm... well, I do have 4x 6TB 7200RPM SATA drives I was planning to use for something else, but I guess I could just use them for this.
-
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dashrender said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
Maybe I should see if I can install Hyper-V on an SD card.. I have an iDRAC with the card slot
No, don't do that. MS used to semi-support that long ago. Now they do not at all.
k then.. I guess I'll just leave the single SSD in and finish installing it to that. I started the install process to one Intel SSD then paused to come post my questions here.
FYI, this is a complete waste of a SSD drive. More IOPs wasted on something that can't/won't use it.
Why are you setting up Hyper-V today when you don't have drives to store the VM's on? Why not wait until you buy those 6+ large HDDs and make a OBR10 and install Hyper-V on there.
It doesn't need to be 8 drives, 6 is fine if that gives you the storage you need. Hyper-V install itself is pretty small, I'm guessing 20 GB or less.
Hmm... well, I do have 4x 6TB 7200RPM SATA drives I was planning to use for something else, but I guess I could just use them for this.
Maybe you should list all of the drives that you have to work with, and we can guide from there.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dashrender said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
@dave247 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
Maybe I should see if I can install Hyper-V on an SD card.. I have an iDRAC with the card slot
No, don't do that. MS used to semi-support that long ago. Now they do not at all.
k then.. I guess I'll just leave the single SSD in and finish installing it to that. I started the install process to one Intel SSD then paused to come post my questions here.
FYI, this is a complete waste of a SSD drive. More IOPs wasted on something that can't/won't use it.
Why are you setting up Hyper-V today when you don't have drives to store the VM's on? Why not wait until you buy those 6+ large HDDs and make a OBR10 and install Hyper-V on there.
It doesn't need to be 8 drives, 6 is fine if that gives you the storage you need. Hyper-V install itself is pretty small, I'm guessing 20 GB or less.
Hmm... well, I do have 4x 6TB 7200RPM SATA drives I was planning to use for something else, but I guess I could just use them for this.
Maybe you should list all of the drives that you have to work with, and we can guide from there.
haha.. sorry.. ok so I have 4x 6TB drives and then I have a ton of 2.5" 300GB 10k and 15k SAS drives, but the problem here is I only have a couple of 2.5" to 3.5" caddie spacers.. I'd have to really dig to find more.
So if I just wanted to use the 4x 6TB drives, would I create a RAID array and then create two separate volumes on that, one for Hyper-V and one for storage, or just have one volume and install Hyper-V to that?
-
So with 4x 6TB drives in RAID 10 (the only option with four drives other than RAID 0 because RAID 5 would be insane, even in a lab) you might as well go with your original ideal of putting in as many SSD or 15K drives as you can get caddies for, making a smaller array of those, and using that, too. Can you get four and four?
-
@scottalanmiller said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
you might as well go with your original ideal of putting in as many SSD or 15K drives as you can get caddies for, making a smaller array of those, and using that, too. Can you get four and four?
Are you saying use 4+ SSD or 15k drives in RIAD10 and making the smaller array and using it for only Hyper-V - in addition to another RAID10 array for storage?
-
If you go with SSD's you'd use OBR5.
If you went with 15K drives you'd use OBR6.
-
@dustinb3403 said in Enterprise 15K SAS drives vs consumer grade SSD in a Dell server?:
If you go with SSD's you'd use OBR5.
If you went with 15K drives you'd use OBR6.
Why?
