Pertino Questions
-
OK, I think we've burned through the initial ipv6 vs 4 situation with pertino.
now i'm having another problem.....
I've got the perfect storm situation...trying to get these folks working remotely on our emr
Windows Home Premium workstation... dumb I know but it's what I've got to work with right now.
EMR has some requirements within DNS for CNAMEs example srsfile that points to sql.ad.com sql is a real server, srsfile is the alias.
When they are on site, I have created a batch file that creates static maps to the 5-6 servers and aliases they required. works fine. doesn't work remotely. any idea/help?
-
Edit the hosts file. Or setup a Linux DNS server and put pertino on it.
-
fixed it with the help of tom @ pertino. dude's a champion -
If that is connecting to your AD DNS then you'd need CALs for these home premium devices.
-
@thecreativeone91 said:
If that is connecting to your AD DNS then you'd need CALs for these home premium devices.
Really? just for DNS?
So all those companies that do BOYD and allow employee cell phones on the network and are using their AD for DNS need a CAL just for DNS access?
-
@Dashrender said:
@thecreativeone91 said:
If that is connecting to your AD DNS then you'd need CALs for these home premium devices.
Really? just for DNS?
So all those companies that do BOYD and allow employee cell phones on the network and are using their AD for DNS need a CAL just for DNS access?
Yeah, I agree with @Dashrender. You're not joining them to the domain, so I don't see how you'd need CALs for this. Using just DNS, you don't get any GPO features, or the like that comes with it being actually joined the domain, which we both know isn't even possible for the home edition without hacking the OS.
-
According to Microsoft, any feature of the server, whether DNS/DHCP you need a CAL.
Most organisations get around that with user cals rather than device cals.
Just because everyone is doing it, does not mean they can keep doing it
That's why these audits are so profitable for Microsoft. -
@thanksajdotcom actually you don't have join AD to require a CAL, just use resources, I thought it was specific resources like file/print services/authentication, etc... would never have figured DNS required CALs though or DHCP (Does DHCP require a CAL too?)
-
Have a read of this.
-
@Breffni-Potter said:
According to Microsoft, any feature of the server, whether DNS/DHCP you need a CAL.
Most organisations get around that with user cals rather than device cals.
Just because everyone is doing it, does not mean they can keep doing it That's why these audits are so profitable for Microsoft.OK would a User CAL cover an employee who is covered by a User CAL at the office for their home computer?
-
@Dashrender said:
@Breffni-Potter said:
According to Microsoft, any feature of the server, whether DNS/DHCP you need a CAL.
Most organisations get around that with user cals rather than device cals.
Just because everyone is doing it, does not mean they can keep doing it That's why these audits are so profitable for Microsoft.OK would a User CAL cover an employee who is covered by a User CAL at the office for their home computer?
I would assume so. If it's the user who is covered, then it seems they wouldn't care what device they used.
-
I as Breffni Potter have a user cal.
That enables me to use my desktop/laptop/IPhone/Printer/VOIP Phone/Network controllable LED light.
If anyone else uses my devices for work, then my user cal is void and we now need 2x user cals.
-
@Breffni-Potter said:
Have a read of this.
Q2 - If I have guests that come into my office an temporarily use a Windows DHCP server to grab an IP address to access the Internet, do they need CALs? I guess the takeaway is to never use a Windows DHCP server?
A2 - Yes, they are using a Windows Server service and would need a CAL.
Well - there we have it.. if you use DHCP for guests you need CALs - damn what a racquet.
-
@Dashrender said:
@Breffni-Potter said:
Have a read of this.
Q2 - If I have guests that come into my office an temporarily use a Windows DHCP server to grab an IP address to access the Internet, do they need CALs? I guess the takeaway is to never use a Windows DHCP server?
A2 - Yes, they are using a Windows Server service and would need a CAL.
Well - there we have it.. if you use DHCP for guests you need CALs - damn what a racquet.
My question is how would Microsoft track this? I mean, you have someone come in and grab an IP once, you are saying you technically have to purchase an additional CAL for them? That seems extreme.
-
@thanksajdotcom said:
@Dashrender said:
@Breffni-Potter said:
Have a read of this.
Q2 - If I have guests that come into my office an temporarily use a Windows DHCP server to grab an IP address to access the Internet, do they need CALs? I guess the takeaway is to never use a Windows DHCP server?
A2 - Yes, they are using a Windows Server service and would need a CAL.
Well - there we have it.. if you use DHCP for guests you need CALs - damn what a racquet.
My question is how would Microsoft track this? I mean, you have someone come in and grab an IP once, you are saying you technically have to purchase an additional CAL for them? That seems extreme.
I mean, assuming you have a reasonable DHCP lease time, of say 24 hours, once their lease is up, if they haven't grabbed it again, they're gone for good. This is one of those things that Microsoft may say that technically additional CALs would be required, but for this kind of situation I doubt it is ever really enforced.
-
@thanksajdotcom said:
@Dashrender said:
@Breffni-Potter said:
Have a read of this.
Q2 - If I have guests that come into my office an temporarily use a Windows DHCP server to grab an IP address to access the Internet, do they need CALs? I guess the takeaway is to never use a Windows DHCP server?
A2 - Yes, they are using a Windows Server service and would need a CAL.
Well - there we have it.. if you use DHCP for guests you need CALs - damn what a racquet.
My question is how would Microsoft track this? I mean, you have someone come in and grab an IP once, you are saying you technically have to purchase an additional CAL for them? That seems extreme.
Yes, the Blog specifically says if you have a guest get a DHCP address for nothing more than surfing the web, you still need a CAL.
CALs are re assignable after 90 days I think, but still, this is absurd! I guess I need to purchase about 20 more CALs just so we have a rotating pool of CALs for reps who come onsite. Either that or stand up some other box, create a completely separate network, etc, etc for the reps to use.
-
@thanksajdotcom said:
@thanksajdotcom said:
@Dashrender said:
@Breffni-Potter said:
Have a read of this.
Q2 - If I have guests that come into my office an temporarily use a Windows DHCP server to grab an IP address to access the Internet, do they need CALs? I guess the takeaway is to never use a Windows DHCP server?
A2 - Yes, they are using a Windows Server service and would need a CAL.
Well - there we have it.. if you use DHCP for guests you need CALs - damn what a racquet.
My question is how would Microsoft track this? I mean, you have someone come in and grab an IP once, you are saying you technically have to purchase an additional CAL for them? That seems extreme.
I mean, assuming you have a reasonable DHCP lease time, of say 24 hours, once their lease is up, if they haven't grabbed it again, they're gone for good. This is one of those things that Microsoft may say that technically additional CALs would be required, but for this kind of situation I doubt it is ever really enforced.
CALs have always been on the honor system, doesn't mean if you get audited you won't have a lot 'splaining to do Lucy!
-
@Dashrender said:
@thanksajdotcom said:
@thanksajdotcom said:
@Dashrender said:
@Breffni-Potter said:
Have a read of this.
Q2 - If I have guests that come into my office an temporarily use a Windows DHCP server to grab an IP address to access the Internet, do they need CALs? I guess the takeaway is to never use a Windows DHCP server?
A2 - Yes, they are using a Windows Server service and would need a CAL.
Well - there we have it.. if you use DHCP for guests you need CALs - damn what a racquet.
My question is how would Microsoft track this? I mean, you have someone come in and grab an IP once, you are saying you technically have to purchase an additional CAL for them? That seems extreme.
I mean, assuming you have a reasonable DHCP lease time, of say 24 hours, once their lease is up, if they haven't grabbed it again, they're gone for good. This is one of those things that Microsoft may say that technically additional CALs would be required, but for this kind of situation I doubt it is ever really enforced.
CALs have always been on the honor system, doesn't mean if you get audited you won't have a lot 'splaining to do Lucy!
Yeah, but they'd have to do some serious digging to find out that you had some sales rep show up one time eight months ago for a few hours and get a DHCP lease and use the DNS of the network.
-
this is why I hate posting here. who said anything about CALs @thecreativeone91 ?????
-
@Dashrender said:
@thanksajdotcom said:
@Dashrender said:
@Breffni-Potter said:
Have a read of this.
Q2 - If I have guests that come into my office an temporarily use a Windows DHCP server to grab an IP address to access the Internet, do they need CALs? I guess the takeaway is to never use a Windows DHCP server?
A2 - Yes, they are using a Windows Server service and would need a CAL.
Well - there we have it.. if you use DHCP for guests you need CALs - damn what a racquet.
My question is how would Microsoft track this? I mean, you have someone come in and grab an IP once, you are saying you technically have to purchase an additional CAL for them? That seems extreme.
Yes, the Blog specifically says if you have a guest get a DHCP address for nothing more than surfing the web, you still need a CAL.
CALs are re assignable after 90 days I think, but still, this is absurd! I guess I need to purchase about 20 more CALs just so we have a rotating pool of CALs for reps who come onsite. Either that or stand up some other box, create a completely separate network, etc, etc for the reps to use.
Yeah, I guess this is why you spin up a guest network on your router and have it use the router as the DHCP server and DNS via Google/L3/OpenDNS servers.
