Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative "
-
Just saw a 4 page topic on PBX choices that @scottalanmiller and @JaredBusch were pretty heavily posting on. You can read it here
Summary - Use FreePBX (with this ISO)
-
It's not there yet, and whether it ever will be is unknown. I would have more faith in Wazo at this point as a long term FreePBX competitor.
If you are looking for something free and asterisk based there is a community version of sipwise CPBX. They have class 4 and 5 softswitches that are used a lot throughout Europe. I several paid products in production in years past. They also use Kamailio and SEMS, as well as some of Jitsi's technology.
At least I hope there is still a free community version..
-
@alyragab said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
Is there anyone who checked and worked with Issabel "the alternative application of Elastix "
Elastix has been dead for so long, and FreePBX picked up the space from it. What's even the purpose of Issabel at this point? I appreciate wanting PBX alternatives, but we already have a few. Is another one needed, especially one that is basically just copying FreePBX?
I'm not opposed to it, and maybe I'll give it a try at some point. But it seems like an odd project to have out there splintering the support community even further. Do they add a twist on to the Asterisk + FreePBX space that makes them important in some way? Wazo does some really different stuff from FreePBX. But FreePBX is the definitive Asterisk + FreePBX distro these days, so Issabel has a pretty up hill battle to relevance.
Hopefully someone from Issabel will hop in here and talk about goals and value proposition. I'm certainly interested, but my interest in it is certainly behind FreePBX and Wazo which are established as the leaders.
-
Mod note: I edited the OP with a link to the project.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
Mod note: I edited the OP with a link to the project.
And tags I noticed.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
@alyragab said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
Is there anyone who checked and worked with Issabel "the alternative application of Elastix "
Elastix has been dead for so long, and FreePBX picked up the space from it. What's even the purpose of Issabel at this point? I appreciate wanting PBX alternatives, but we already have a few. Is another one needed, especially one that is basically just copying FreePBX?
I'm not opposed to it, and maybe I'll give it a try at some point. But it seems like an odd project to have out there splintering the support community even further. Do they add a twist on to the Asterisk + FreePBX space that makes them important in some way? Wazo does some really different stuff from FreePBX. But FreePBX is the definitive Asterisk + FreePBX distro these days, so Issabel has a pretty up hill battle to relevance.
Hopefully someone from Issabel will hop in here and talk about goals and value proposition. I'm certainly interested, but my interest in it is certainly behind FreePBX and Wazo which are established as the leaders.
Yeah, I was trying not to be rude as I know people are trying to make that a go, but it reminds me of the BeOS project, Haiku or whatever. I stopped giving money 10 years ago when I realized it wasnt going to get anywhere like BeOS did. Also Q#$%#$ to Palm for ruining BeOS.
-
@dustinb3403 That SW thread is absolute insanity. The OP's logic is tragically backwards. Just install the damn thing and try it..
-
@alyragab said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
Is there anyone who checked and worked with Issabel "the alternative application of Elastix "
I need to know your experience about it , and is it reliable ?
ThanksIssabel is simply some people trying to continue Elastix after PaloSanto Solutions failed and sold to 3CX.
It is certainly not solid yet.
-
@bnrstnr said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
@dustinb3403 That SW thread is absolute insanity. The OP's logic is tragically backwards. Just install the damn thing and try it..
Yeah there is a lot going on in that topic.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
@alyragab said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
Is there anyone who checked and worked with Issabel "the alternative application of Elastix "
Elastix has been dead for so long, and FreePBX picked up the space from it. What's even the purpose of Issabel at this point? I appreciate wanting PBX alternatives, but we already have a few. Is another one needed, especially one that is basically just copying FreePBX?
I'm not opposed to it, and maybe I'll give it a try at some point. But it seems like an odd project to have out there splintering the support community even further. Do they add a twist on to the Asterisk + FreePBX space that makes them important in some way? Wazo does some really different stuff from FreePBX. But FreePBX is the definitive Asterisk + FreePBX distro these days, so Issabel has a pretty up hill battle to relevance.
Hopefully someone from Issabel will hop in here and talk about goals and value proposition. I'm certainly interested, but my interest in it is certainly behind FreePBX and Wazo which are established as the leaders.
WTF are you talking about @scottalanmiller
There are not many FOSS solutions out there. Some would argue the only one out there is Wazo and Issabel because of the lack of clarity that FreePBX offers.
The FreePBX GUI may be FOSS, but the rest of the distro most certainly is not.
For all that Sangoma says they are committed to open source, they have not changed any of Schmooze's commercial modules to FOSS.
None of that stops a FreePBX system without commercial modules from working well, but it is most certainly not a fully FOSS solution.
The biggest thing that Elastix included, that users used a lot, was outbound faxing. FreePBX only offers this in a paid commercial module, and I think only with their own carrier SIPStation as the trunk.
Of course you can use an ATA and it will generally work, but that is not the same thing as an integrated solution.
Also, as you so often point out, this is the entire point of FOSS. Protection from a company going out of business. Issabel has taken the project and updated to CentOS 7, and began to stabilize the product. You cannot have this both ways.
All of that said, Issabel is not exactly a FreePBX competitor. It is still the FreePBX GUI on the backend. It is a competitor for the FreePBX distro, but it is not a wholly different solution.
The only wholly different solution that I am aware of in the FOSS space is Wazo (formerly Xivo).
-
@bigbear said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
@scottalanmiller said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
@alyragab said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
Is there anyone who checked and worked with Issabel "the alternative application of Elastix "
Elastix has been dead for so long, and FreePBX picked up the space from it. What's even the purpose of Issabel at this point? I appreciate wanting PBX alternatives, but we already have a few. Is another one needed, especially one that is basically just copying FreePBX?
I'm not opposed to it, and maybe I'll give it a try at some point. But it seems like an odd project to have out there splintering the support community even further. Do they add a twist on to the Asterisk + FreePBX space that makes them important in some way? Wazo does some really different stuff from FreePBX. But FreePBX is the definitive Asterisk + FreePBX distro these days, so Issabel has a pretty up hill battle to relevance.
Hopefully someone from Issabel will hop in here and talk about goals and value proposition. I'm certainly interested, but my interest in it is certainly behind FreePBX and Wazo which are established as the leaders.
Yeah, I was trying not to be rude as I know people are trying to make that a go, but it reminds me of the BeOS project, Haiku or whatever. I stopped giving money 10 years ago when I realized it wasnt going to get anywhere like BeOS did. Also Q#$%#$ to Palm for ruining BeOS.
BeOS you say?
-
@jaredbusch said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
Also, as you so often point out, this is the entire point of FOSS. Protection from a company going out of business. Issabel has taken the project and updated to CentOS 7, and began to stabilize the product. You cannot have this both ways.
I agree, the question is, is it adding something to the ecosystem that FreePBX is failing to provide? If so, great. Certainly getting away from the commercial add ons would be wonderful.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
@jaredbusch said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
Also, as you so often point out, this is the entire point of FOSS. Protection from a company going out of business. Issabel has taken the project and updated to CentOS 7, and began to stabilize the product. You cannot have this both ways.
I agree, the question is, is it adding something to the ecosystem that FreePBX is failing to provide? If so, great. Certainly getting away from the commercial add ons would be wonderful.
And that answer is yes, just because it contains all the pieces that Elastix had.
-
Is Issabel still in Ecuador? I noticed that their feeds are still in Spanish like Elastix was.
-
The reason that I don't trust issabel yet is because they have not made (that I have found) their code public anywhere yet.
They made a github account but the code is not there.
During early beta, they used to reference an install script on repo.issbel.org but that no longer works.
-
@jaredbusch said in Issabel PBX " Elastix Alternative ":
The reason that I don't trust issabel yet is because they have not made (that I have found) their code public anywhere yet.
They made a github account but the code is not there.
During early beta, they used to reference an install script on repo.issbel.org but that no longer works.
Oh, good point. I had not looked to see what was on their GitHub.
-
Surprised you guys never look at FreeSwitch? I know it's aimed more at the carrier voice market but it makes a decent PBX (There are GUI packages). It was designed for multi-tenancy and call centers which are another really nice to have the more advanced feature set.
-
@john-nicholson freeswitch is a competitor to asterisk, not freepbx. It's gear more towards developers.
There was a project called bluebox that akin to the early Freepbx. It was a GUI for freeswith. But those guys mostly work on another project now that focuses on carrier solutions.
There is Fusion PBX which is still very active, and similar to FreePBX. It is geared towards multiple servers and redundancy rather than a single box deployment
-
@john-nicholson It has beena few years since I looked at FreeSwitch as a choice for a stand alone PBX and it simply was not there for the layman.
You are right that I have not looked in recent years. I will have to remedy that.
-
@bigbear I've used the platform for PBX use cases (partially because it was more robust than Asterisk back in the day when I was a VOIP guy). I know a DEV who's done some of the work on the windows builds (Old boss) is why I ask. I know a lot of call center people who've abandoned Asterisk for it.
