Unsolved analog video stream
-
@DustinB3403 said in analog video stream:
@scottalanmiller said in analog video stream:
@Mike-Davis said in analog video stream:
@DustinB3403 said in analog video stream:
I was figuring something like mount a camera to a wall.
yes, that would be the best option. Is there an option to do that for $1,000?
Did you look at the TP-Link stuff? Their stuff is cheap, but tends to work. I know a few people like them more than I do
The issue I see with the TP-Link stuff is that it likely doesn't have a good enough fps or zoom capabilities... but maybe their newer stuff does.
FPS I would see as an issue (see what I did there?) But zoom I'm thinking would not matter.
-
Honestly, grab an iPhone and Facebook Live it. Done.
-
As long as the entire congregation doesn't also connect to the wifi and try to watch it at the same time, ha ha.
-
@scottalanmiller said in analog video stream:
Honestly, grab an iPhone and Facebook Live it. Done.
As easy as that is, it's slapped together which @Mike-Davis wanted to avoid.
-
@dafyre said in analog video stream:
As long as the entire congregation doesn't also connect to the wifi and try to watch it at the same time, ha ha.
Yeah... probably not a big risk.
-
@DustinB3403 said in analog video stream:
@scottalanmiller said in analog video stream:
Honestly, grab an iPhone and Facebook Live it. Done.
As easy as that is, it's slapped together which @Mike-Davis wanted to avoid.
I don't know, using analogue is pretty slapped together
-
@scottalanmiller said in analog video stream:
@DustinB3403 said in analog video stream:
@scottalanmiller said in analog video stream:
Honestly, grab an iPhone and Facebook Live it. Done.
As easy as that is, it's slapped together which @Mike-Davis wanted to avoid.
I don't know, using analogue is pretty slapped together
I think that the analog conversation came in from the idea of having to connect to a TV using CC cameras.
-
@DustinB3403 said in analog video stream:
@scottalanmiller said in analog video stream:
@DustinB3403 said in analog video stream:
@scottalanmiller said in analog video stream:
Honestly, grab an iPhone and Facebook Live it. Done.
As easy as that is, it's slapped together which @Mike-Davis wanted to avoid.
I don't know, using analogue is pretty slapped together
I think that the analog conversation came in from the idea of having to connect to a TV using CC cameras.
Exactly
-
Which the CCTV solution is still completely do-able, but an ancient way of doing what is asked of.
Streaming is the only current and future forward approach here, even if it is LAN only streaming.
-
@Mike-Davis Your basic simple solution is an everyday camcorder with HDMI out and an HDMI splitter.
My Sony Handicam from 2005 had HDMI out, and a remote control. so you don't even need to be able to reach the unit most of the time. Just mount it on the wall. Gives you the option to record even if you put a card in it.
It is buried in a box at the moment or I would hook it up and test it to prove the functionality.
-
Have not looked at this, but what about a GoPro? That has HDMI out and has good audio and is super simple to use.
-
@scottalanmiller said in analog video stream:
Have not looked at this, but what about a GoPro? That has HDMI out and has good audio and is super simple to use.
Another good choice if the HDMI is active as a "monitor" for the the unit.
-
Any budget in mind? If they don't have a computer that you can use for this purpose I would consider buying something like an Intel Nuc and just doing it through IP's. The cost saved by using a Raspberry Pi is going to increase the labor cost. If you're doing it pro-bono (unsure fi you're a member of the church) then that's really up to you.
-
@wirestyle22 said in analog video stream:
Any budget in mind? If they don't have a computer that you can use for this purpose I would consider buying something like an Intel Nuc and just doing it through IP's.
Over complicated. The point is to have nothing but the hardware.
-
couldn't you do hdmi over ethernet?
-
@wirestyle22 said in analog video stream:
couldn't you do hdmi over ethernet?
He can after he splits it sure.
If needed -
@wirestyle22 said in analog video stream:
Any budget in mind? If they don't have a computer that you can use for this purpose I would consider buying something like an Intel Nuc and just doing it through IP's. The cost saved by using a Raspberry Pi is going to increase the labor cost. If you're doing it pro-bono (unsure fi you're a member of the church) then that's really up to you.
Budget price for the job I believe is 1000 or under
-
So I tested out VLC and OBS. Both are pretty cool and I learned a bit by messing with them. In the end I don't think either will meet my needs for now.
VLC had no problem letting me select my webcam I could see the live video. There was a 1 second delay with the video and audio viewing it locally. Then I set up a http stream and viewed that with VLC player on my laptop. There is a 30 second delay on a wired connection. That would have been acceptable except I couldn't find anyway to view the stream on my Samsung smart TV.
So then I downloaded OBS https://obsproject.com/ Thanks @DustinB3403
This is a cool program that answered another question I had, but in the end doesn't work for this application because there is no way (that I could find) to stream it to a TV. It's set up to stream to commercial stream services, but not to your own. This guy figured out how to put together all the pieces to set up a custom server that VLC can read from, but there again, I can figure out how to get my TV to connect to the stream. https://obsproject.com/forum/threads/custom-stream-option-and-vlc-under-windows-fixed-with-instruction.15925/ -
@Mike-Davis in those cases, you'd not use the TV directly but get a cheaper TV that doesn't have a media system built in and connect it to a Roku or Raspberry Pi or something else simple that will handle the decoding.
-
@scottalanmiller said in analog video stream:
@Mike-Davis in those cases, you'd not use the TV directly but get a cheaper TV that doesn't have a media system built in and connect it to a Roku or Raspberry Pi or something else simple that will handle the decoding.
Yes, and again, that gets out of your scope. I seriously think your best choice will be a standard camcorder, HDMI splitter, and long HDMI cables to the other rooms. If Long HDMI is not going to work, then HDMI to Ethernet converters.
